Famous last words: the myth of er no one knows exactly what to do with the final book of plato's republic the dialogue itself is concerned with justice – what is justice and why should one bother being just there are some exciting asides, thoughts on politics and psychology, as well as expositions of plato's. The myth of er is the epilogue of plato's republic it could be considered as an independent text that refers to the greatest philosophical question of all times where does our soul go when we die and where does it come from when we are born socrates in order to give an answer that would lead to a safe conclusion. The myth of er can argument be presented in the form of myth what more does myth offer that simple argument is unable to provide what lies between the simple spoken words of myth that is conveyed as a whole through its telling and what might be lost in using such a form of argument plato ends. The cambridge companion to plato's republic edited by g r f ferrari book doi: online isbn: 9781139001557 hardback isbn: 9780521839631 paperback isbn: 9780521548427 chapter 16 - the life-and-death journey of the soul: interpreting the myth of er pp 445-. Other articles where myth of er is discussed:platonic philosophy, illustrated in the myth of er in plato's republic, in which a slain warrior named er is revived briefly on his funeral pyre and tells of what he has seen of the fate of souls after death the lengthy account includes a description of reincarnation and of the. Why should you care about myth of er in platoâ€™s the republic we have the the myth of er is essentially the 411 on the afterlife just like in other words, plato is concerned that not everyone will buy, or have the intelligence to understand, his fancy-pants philosophical explanations for the benefit of justice so what.
Rereading plato's republic through er: the clash of the political and the theoretical readers have long been puzzled about why plato concludes the republic with the myth of er the key question, as johnson has suggested, is whether er “does any philosophical work” or offers instead a kind of poetic mimesis (johnson. The fate of persephone is but one of many glimpses into the underworld found in greek myths there are many accounts of the afterlife in various myths, but the fullest descriptions of the underworld are found in book 11 of homer's odyssey ( circa 750 bce) and the “myth of er” in plato's republic (circa 400 bce) just as. The myth of er: a meditation on the value of true belief in plato's republic a thesis presented to the division of literature and languages reed college in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree bachelor of arts cecilia d' anastasio may 2013 approved for the division (classics) walter englert.
There are also in plato myths that are his own, such as the myth of er (republic 621b8) or the myth of atlantis (timaeus 26e4) many of the myths plato invented feature characters and motifs taken from traditional mythology (such as the isles of the blessed or the judgment after death), and sometimes it is. At the end of plato's republic (written around 400-300 bc), a warrior named er, who “died” in battle, observed a towering band of light resembling a rainbow, only brighter and purer it seemed to be a passageway by which souls journey back and forth to earth most western philosophers and other scholars. Plato uses the myth of er in the republic in order to carve out space for political freedom and responsibility for human freedom in the ordinary polis while much of the republic concentrates on the development of an ideal city in speech, that city is fundamentally a mythos presented in order for socrates and his friends to. The myth of er from plato's republic tells the story of a soldier, er, who is thought to be dead and descends to the underworld but when he revives he is sent back to tell humanity what awaits them in the afterlife er describes an afterlife where the just are rewarded and the wicked are punished souls are.
Plato's republic, book x: the poets and the myth of er the final book of plato's republic begins with socrates returning to the question of banishing the poets that was first addressed in book iii book x is perhaps the most vexing and troubling book in the republic book x serves as a kind of epilogue,. “it is not, let me tell you,” said i, “the tale to alcinous told that i shall unfold, but the tale of a warrior bold, er, the son of armenius, by race a pamphylian he once upon a time was slain in battle, and when the corpses were taken up on the tenth day already decayed, was found intact, and having been brought home, at the. [in book 10 of his republic, plato has socrates tell the story of the vision of er, an allegory concerning the fate of human souls after death and the way in which their next life on earth is determined the following is the jowett translation (§§ 614-621) -- ed] i will tell you a tale not one of the tales which odysseus tells to the.
This video is about the myth of er in plato's republic (50. A summary of book x in plato's the republic learn exactly what happened in this chapter, scene, or section of the republic and this argument, based on the myth of er, appeals to the rewards which the just will receive in the afterlife according to the myth, a warrior named er is killed in battle, but does not really die. Plato closes the republic by telling the story of er's journey in the afterlife as a way of making the point that we need always to choose virtue in this one.
Story adapted from: dougherty, william the vision of er by plato the vision of er by plato theosophical university press, june-july 1998 web 6 dec. Bloom, though, also has another plausible hypothesis for why plato included the myth of er, and this one coheres well with our understanding of justice's worth the myth of er, bloom explains, illustrates once again the necessity of philosophy the civic virtues alone are not enough only the philosophers. Plato's “myth of er” and ezekiel's “throne vision” numen 64 (2017) 153–182 the vision of er in plato's republic1 as stated above, er and his deceased companions, journeying in the after- world, discern, at a distance, “extended from above throughout the heaven and the earth, a straight light like a pillar, most nearly. In the republic plato develops this idea of the living coming from the dead even further the myth of er is a story plato has socrates tell his audience, glaucon, about er, a man chosen to witness the workings of the underworld plato uses this story to support his theories that humans have an immortal soul.
Three major ancient authors taken together provide a composite and virtually complete summary of the philosophical and religious beliefs about the afterlife evolved by the greeks and romans homer, odyssey, book 11, the nekuia (“the book of the dead”) plato, republic, the myth of er, which concludes book 10 vergil. The myth of er is a legend that concludes plato's republic (10614–10621) the story includes an account of the cosmos and the afterlife that greatly influenced religious, philosophical, and scientific thought for many centuries the story begins as a man named er (/ɜːr/ greek: ἤρ, gen: ἠρός (not to be confused with. The myth of er is a tale in greek mythology about a man who died on a battlefield and returned to life nine days later, recounting what happened in th. Plato was a prominent philosopher in classical greece and author of the republic in the conclusion to the republic we encounter the “myth of er” and are provided with a vivid depiction of the soul's journey through the underworld er was a hero who died in battle ten days after his death as he lay on the funeral pyre.